I’ve been browsing bookshelves again. But instead of my usual bookstore hangout, I’ve been browsing online. My agent is getting my newest proposal ready to send out and asked for comparables. This is where I have to find titles published by the publishers I hope will publish my book. Wow, that’s a lot of publishing in one sentence. So I’ve been searching online until I’m cross-eyed and have a headache for Inspy Contemporary Romance with similar characters or topics to mine. It took me a full week to find 3 comparables for each of the 3 books in my proposal. But while I was at it, I discovered some authors I’ve never read that I want to try. And I saw lots of lovely covers.
When I’m looking for a book to read, I’m bad to stick to my standbys because I have little time to read. But sometimes a cover will capture my attention. If it’s Inspy Contemporary, I automatically read the back cover. If the story piques my interest, I’ll buy it. But sometimes, I’ll buy a book just on the basis of the cover. Or even the title. Becky Wade got me with the pink shoes. This was the first of her books that I read. Now she’s a standby. When her books release, I buy them. All because of the pink shoes.
Have I mentioned I own about sixty pairs of shoes? About 42 heels in every color you can think of including pink, yellow, and gold. Why wear black when you can wear red or leopard or silver? Then there are about a dozen sandals, 4 boots, and the rest are tennis shoes. I also have matching issues. If my pants are gray, my sandals have to be silver or my tennis shoes have to be gray. Okay, enough about shoes.
Or maybe not. While browsing for comparables, I found Courtney Walsh. I’ve heard of her, but never read her. But while trying to find books similar to mine, I discovered several of her covers and back covers that interested me. Again, she had me with the boots. And come to think of it, even though I have black, red, leopard, and snakeskin boots, I don’t have any rain boots. Hmm, I need to fix that. I have a pair of camo really ugly all-weather boots. They were an old pair of my son’s he’s outgrown. They’re great for snow, mud, and cleaning out the pool. But I’d never, ever, ever wear them in public. But these cute yellow polka dotted ones. Yep, I’d wear them. And I ordered the book from Mardel’s today while my husband browsed Bibles for a new member.
Whenever I see great covers that make me want to buy them, I wonder how much input the author had. Maybe big-name authors get to change and revise until it’s perfect. As for small-name authors like me, I fill out a questionnaire and send pictures of models for my characters. Then I got a draft and all that can be changed is hair or eye color. And only slightly. I’ve had the cover that had the girl sitting between the guy’s legs in a strapless top. When I saw it, I was like, oh my. My mama told me never to sit between a man’s legs unless we were married. My characters weren’t married and the strapless top wasn’t what I consider modest. I had readers ask me about it, so it wasn’t just me. And that cover was with one of the most conservative publishers.
Another book pictured my hero with a mullet. Not how I described him and in the years when that hairstyle was decidedly out. Then there was the cover where the guy’s eyes were awesomely green like I wrote them when I got the online draft. But when the books came, his eyes were decidedly brown. The one where I talked about the heroine hating her naturally curly hair throughout the book. But on the cover, her hair was straight and a lot shorter than I’d written. The cover where the cowboy’s belt buckle was upside down and no one noticed. Except for a reader. For A Texas Bond, when I got the draft I complained that the hero didn’t look like a cowboy. Only to learn that they weren’t using live models due to that virus we’re all sick of, so the artist had to find cover art online. I felt bad for saying anything that time.
Don’t get me wrong, I’ve had some good ones too. Hill Country Redemption is my favorite. Because, well, look at him. The cover artist nailed my vision for Rance Shepherd. He looks a lot like the model I sent. I also loved my cover for Counting on the Cowboy. They made Colson really hunky and spot on with the model I used.
Rodeo Song is one of my favorites. That book was based on a dream I had after a Michael Bolton concert (yes I’m that old). During the concert, Michael took a break and ran around the lobby, where I happened to be. A friend and I followed the hoards running after him and I stood within six feet of him when he sang Georgia on My Mind. How did he know I grew up in Georgia? Don’t worry, my husband was there, waiting for me in the stands. And when I dreamed that night that Michael took my hand, pulled me on stage with him, and sang Georgia to me, then asked me to have dinner with him, I said, “I’m married.” And woke up.
But it made a great book. The cover art I sent for that one was Tim McGraw and Faith Hill standing and singing to each other. The cover artist did a great job of turning the scene into my hero singing to my heroine seated on a stool, just like the scene in the book.
More of my favorite covers. The first Denise Hunter book I read was The Accidental Bride. For this one, it was the title that hooked me. How do you become an accidental bride? And the look on her face intrigued me. I’d have bought this book even if the back cover didn’t sound interesting, simply because the title did. After I read this book, I binge-bought all of Denise’s backlist and binge-read them. When her books release, I buy them. All because of this title.
Like Never Before wasn’t my first title from Melissa Tagg. Her first book, Made to Last was the first I read of hers. The back cover sold me on it. I liked it so much she became a standby and I buy her books as soon as they release. But this is my favorite cover of hers. I love them wrapped in the blanket looking so cozy. The color of the blanket makes me think of fall. My favorite season. And I love how she’s all up in his face and he seems kind of shy.
So what about you? What are some of your favorite covers? What do you love about them? Does the cover sell you on a book? Or the back cover blurb? Or like me, the author? What makes you try new authors? All comments will go in the drawing for a print copy of A Texas Bond. Deadline: Aug 17th.
kim hansen says
I read the burb on the back of a book on authors that are new to me. That is how I find new to me reads.
Laurie Larsen says
I love this behind the scenes look at the cover process! Thanks!
Lori Smanski says
welcome and thanks for posting today. Oh I agree that covers really do have a lot to say about the story ahead. I have a lot of favorite covers that make me want to open the pages and get lost. Example: Fights of Fancy, Diamond in the Rough, Storing Up Trouble by Jen Turano (American Heiresses series) All three ladies look like they are up to something and they are not “air heads” , but there is more to the woman. And yes I want to find out. But there are so many others that I am glad I opened them up and went on the adventures with them
Trudy says
I go by author, title, and the blurb on the back. I prefer covers without people on them, mainly because I like to picture the characters myself, but also because I’ve read books where the cover didn’t match the characters at all. I proofread/edit for indie authors, and one makes all of her own covers. She’s painted shirts on men with no shirts on, and because I didn’t like the way his hands were, she covered over them with the book series name. I’ve learned a lot about covers that I never dreamed I’d know! I do find it very interesting, though! Especially after taking Advertising and Marketing in college, though my teacher for both told me I was the person advertiser and marketers hate, because they have to work harder to get me to buy!
Alicia Haney says
Good morning, yes, I love covers, I look at the cover first, the title and then I read the back of the book. Have a great rest of the week and stay safe.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Wow, that’s cool, Kim. I wish all readers would search out new to them authors.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Laurie, my publishing friend wrote a blog about creating the perfect cover. I had no idea so much went into it: https://scriveningspress.com/book-cover-design-its-a-process/?fbclid=IwAR24odNnGpCQsafNxWPI_85OFOkKkAiVuGg7JzMsVfvD3sqBbEIBoVT1yjk
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
I had to check those out, Lori. Historicals have pretty covers. Those dresses.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Trudy, it is annoying when the cover doesn’t match the character. That’s cool that the author changed things for you. She must value your opinion. Most bigger publishers use live models. I think it would be fun to be a cover model.
Grant Vannatter says
Hey Alicia. If it’s contemporary, I read the blurb. Period. I never want to miss a good contemporary.
Kendra Muonio says
I look at cover first then read back cause sometimes they change covers and I will buy the book and realize that I already have read the book .I usually like how all the love inspired book covers look I read love inspired books every month when I they come out.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Kendra, I’ve noticed the cover changing too. I think that happens when the book goes out of print and the author republishes it. I always read the back cover too. And I’m very happy with the new look of Love Inspired.
Debra Pruss says
The cover and author are the selling points for me. Thank you for sharing. God bless you.
bn100 says
skip over books where different authors use the same covers
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Debra, I guess covers come into play for most readers. I guess that’s why publishers put so much work into them.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
I have seen the same cover models on several different books, bn100. But I guess there are only so many models. And smaller publishers use images instead of models.
Dreaa Drake says
The cover always draws me in first, but the blurb is why I one click! ❤️
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
I’m with you on both, Dreaa.
Teresa Warner says
Cute or sexy covers catch my eye. Then I usually read the back cover and see if I think it is about something that I would enjoy!
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Teresa. The consensus seems to be the cover catches the eye, but the back cover blurb cinches the deal. I’m the same way.
Shelia Hall says
I love all the covers for your rodeo series books!
Melynda says
I don’t see book covers as much as I used to now that I read mostly on kindle. When I do see them though, a cute one will definitely entice me to read the blurb. I don’t think I’ve ever bought a book just based on the cover, but I regularly buy books just based on who the author is and having loved their books previously. It’s always so fun to get to the end of a kindle book and be prompted to read the next in series when I’ve loved the book I just finished.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Thanks so much, Shelia. Those were some good covers.
Shannon Taylor Vannatter says
Hey Melynda, I’m still a paperbook gal. I own a few e-books, that don’t come in print, by my favorite authors. But I don’t really feel like I own the book unless it’s lined up on my shelf. That would be fun to go right into the next book though. I’m currently binge-rereading my favorite series. E-books make less of a tbr pile for sure.