You’re just a failure. The sooner you accept it, the better.
Have you ever heard that voice in your head? The one that says you’re not good enough? Maybe, like Arleigh O’Neill, you heard the words out loud from someone who should have been there for you. Someone like a spouse or a beloved parent. In Arleigh’s case, her father.
I haven’t experienced gaslighting personally, but I’ve seen it in action. I’ve seen more than one grown woman – although men can be victims, too – begin to doubt her perception of reality.
You’re not good enough. You’re clumsy. You’re stupid. You’re confused. It didn’t happen that way. You’re paranoid. You’re overreacting. You’re making things up.
No one will believe you.
Because look at me! I’m a pillar of the community. A respected businessman. Possibly a respected church elder. I’m charming. I have everyone fooled.
No one will believe you.
You don’t have any bruises. I would never do anything to hurt you. Not physically, but I do like you to cower a bit in front of me. To remember I’m in control, and you most definitely are not. And besides…
No one will believe you.
As I wrote A Green and Vibrant Hope, the heroine’s background became clear to me. Arleigh’s parents had split up when she was a teenager, when her maternal grandmother finally got through to Arleigh’s mom about how unhealthy her marriage was.
Because Arleigh’s dad had been projecting his reality on his wife and two daughters for many years. But even though Arleigh rarely saw her father anymore, his voice lived on.
As the first scene in the story closes, we read this:
Everything she touched turned to muck in her hands. Her father’s voice barked inside her mind: Get your head out of the clouds, Arleigh Maria. You’ll never amount to anything with all that daydreaming.
Dad was right. Why had she ever thought she could make a go of her own business? She’d risked everything… and lost.
A few chapters later, Arleigh’s sister, Juni, returns to town. They get talking about Dad.
Arleigh poked her booted foot at the table leg. “I could never be enough for Dad. Not like you. All I ever hear is his voice in my head.”
“Wait.” Juni surged to her feet. “You think Dad approved of me more than of you?”
“Duh. He did.”
Juni gave her head a quick shake. “I’m not sure what evidence you have of that.”
“Seriously? Everything I said or did, he told me I would fail. That I wasn’t good enough. That a girl couldn’t handle whatever it was.”
“I’m two years younger than you.”
“Your point?” Arleigh dropped into a chair beside the table and waited while Juni took her seat again. “Because there’s no way I made that up.”
“You didn’t make that up.”
Touché.
“But you weren’t inside my mind watching you butt heads with Dad all the time. You were so brave.”
“Stupid. Not brave.”
“From my angle, you looked brave. You knew he wouldn’t approve, but you kept tackling new ventures regardless. You didn’t let him stop you.”
There was so much Arleigh wanted to say to that. If she’d had a glimmer of hope that he’d approve if she made a different choice, she’d have buckled without another thought.
“Me, on the other hand? I guess I decided to bend and try to please him.” Juni looked down as she twisted her hands together. “It didn’t work over the long haul.”
Meanwhile, Arleigh is getting to know widower and single dad, Mitchell Ackerman, who has a few minor hang-ups of his own where chauvinism is concerned. But, with Arleigh’s background, she blows those possibly little things way out of proportion.
Which is reality? Is Mitchell a nice guy who can love her as Christ loved the church? Or is he merely a more subtle version of her earthly father?
Come join Arleigh and Mitchell as they work through their perceptions of God the Father and the vibrant, living hope found in Him! Even though there are some heavy themes, I think you’ll find it an uplifting read.
Arleigh O’Neill gambles on starting her own flower farm with a tight budget on leased land… and loses when the river overflows its banks, demolishing the rented greenhouse, drowning her fields, and destroying her mobile home. She needs both a home and a job, but no one in Galena Landing seems to be hiring.
Widowed farmer Mitchell Ackerman is at wit’s end with his two rambunctious sons, but his brother’s suggestion he hire Arleigh to nanny the boys is a nonstarter. He can’t afford to pay anyone, and besides, she annoys him with her hippie-flower-painted van and independent attitude. When, after a particularly bad parenting day. Arleigh drives a bargain to care for them in exchange for greenhouse space, Mitchell is in no position to argue.
Arleigh thinks he’s arrogant. Mitchell thinks she’s frivolous. What will it take to get them to see into each other’s hearts and grasp a green and vibrant hope?
A Green and Vibrant Hope releases May 4, 2023, and will be available in Kindle Unlimited. Preorder today for the best price!
Renate says
Hi Valerie! Book preordered and will be another page turning Spring read. Enjoy your day.
RuthieH says
This sounds a great read, looking forward to it! I think it’s so true that this sort of experience absolutely stays with you and colours all your experiences in the future, this sort of emotional abuse and gaslighting is a terrible thing. I’m really looking forward to reading about Arleigh’s experience and maybe finding out more about the relationship with her sister, as well as seeing what happens with Arleigh and Mitchell
Kathleen Mattingly says
This book sounds really interesting!! I look forward to reading it!
Trudy says
Oh, this sounds good! I’ll look forward to reading it!
Valerie Comer says
Thank you so much!
Valerie Comer says
Thank you, Ruthie!
Valerie Comer says
I hope you enjoy it, Kathleen!
Valerie Comer says
Yay, thanks, Trudy!
Margaret Nelson says
Can’t wait to read it! I’ve had it pre-ordered for a long time!
Valerie Comer says
Thank you so much!
Ausjenny says
Gaslighting is interesting. I can see two different situations here. The father’s emotional abuse with the your not good enough which often happens in marriages too where one partner constantly belittles the other to the point they think they really are the issue but they are nice to others. Normally its only in the immediate family and they will come across as caring to others. (My friend had this happen when she left due to it he would say things like I don’t know why she left but I hope she gets the help she needs and one day we will know why making even me think he cared. He didn’t he was abusive and the quit his jobs so he didn’t have to pay anything for his 5 kids).
Then there is the Narcissistic person like the church elder or person in leadership who gaslights the whole congregation but when they start to be seen and then have people stand up or stop enabling them as in a case I know personally the person got another term by one vote meaning over 30% didn’t want them the true colours came out and they made things as hard for everyone as possible.
(I personally have been the victim of people gaslighting me, they go from accusing for something you haven’t done but twist it to make you question if you said something that was taken the wrong way and then next conversation is a nice a pie as if nothing happen. One we had a very uneasy truce where I stopped doing anything more than I had to do and never being in a conversation alone. (If they had asked for a meeting I would have someone with me which then gave me a witness and shut down the gaslighting) the other I will do what I have to but will not engage when they go on rants (it really does frustrate me them). But it can take time to realise you are being gaslit.
I like the sound of your new book. I had things like that with mum my internal dialogue was she thought I wasn’t good enough or was lazy. She didn’t say anything direct but I could feel it and it would be indirect comments. Finally one day she was in the nursing home and told me she didn’t know how I would survive when she went. I wouldn’t be able to pay bills and keep a house and she didn’t know where I would end up. It was actually freeing having her say what I had thought she was thinking. Ironically I paid my own bills, I was able to save etc. but her thinking is if you are not married you can’t possibly look after yourself etc.
Valerie Comer says
Thank you for sharing your experiences. It’s true there are many forms emotional abuse can take, and narcissism often (usually?) plays a role. I’m sorry you’ve been through it.
Debra Pruss says
Thank you so much for sharing. There are so many of us who lived through verbal abuse. God bless you.
Valerie Comer says
Big hugs, Debra. Praying for you right now.
bn100 says
an interesting post
Valerie Comer says
Thanks :)